Monday, October 19, 2009

Two Thousand Years in the Heart of Asia - Chapter 5


Upon reading this chapter, my first impression was an enlightened realization on how valuable that map quiz actually was! Memorizing the places on those two maps as well as reading ‘Foreign Devils’ gave me a much better understanding of the geographical context and people I was so overwhelmed by in my first blog entry.

A first point of interest in this chapter, as briefly discussed in class, was the mummification discoveries. I won’t get into this part too much considering we’ve talked about it already, but the fact that there are methods to trace the general migration pattern of these European ‘Tocharians’ into Loulan from as long as 4000 years ago is simply amazing.

The history of the Sogdians is fascinating because we see the early developments of the trade routes. They were well known as far as Greece because of Alexander the Great, and they appeared to have managed to monopolize a triangle trade route with India and China. The map quiz helped me put a perspective of their general whereabouts because on page 68 it is noted that Panjikent was a Sogdian city, and Samarkand, previously Marakanda, was the Sogdian capital. Now that I can visualize this area, I can see how it was so accessible to Alexander the Great and his army.

After reading the list of items Sogdian merchants transported (I.e. Chinese paper) I believe that it would not be a far stretch to suggest that Sogdian merchants were responsible for the transportation paper manufacturing. The establishment of paper manufacturer in Samarkand in the eight century led to the gradual transmission of paper-making in Europe (67).

Another interesting fact about the Sogdians, is that the Sogdian merchants and travellers were mainly responsible for the spread of Zoroastrianism along the Silk Roads and into China and India. Though the religion was only tolerated in China in the Tang dynasty, the Sogdians can be said to be responsible for Zoroastrian believers that to this day remain in India.

Side note… I loved the bit at the end about Marco Polo. I never knew that he traveled with his family, it’s amusing to me to refer to them as “The Polos.”


Monday, October 12, 2009

Hou Hanshu : Western Regions

I am currently reading the Han Histories [http://depts.washington.edu/silkroad/texts/hhshu/hou_han_shu.html#sec1], and I must admit... the length of this website intimidates me.

Professor Goodman wants us to think about what constitutes historical writing, and if we would classify this piece within this genre. So far I find that there is no doubt in my mind that would consider this work as anything but historical writing. It is compliled by Fan Ye (I looked this up online) who used a number of earlier histories to create his 'official history'. This to me legitmizes Fan Ye's work because the history is created by people who lived and experienced the exact context they are writing about. While this fact makes it fascinating because we are getting almost a first hand account, so far the reading itself is not thoroughly engaging.

Okay, back to the reading...
So far I am so glad that I read the textbook first because it is making this reading much easier to understand.

Will finish this when I'm done reading!

..... *Later*

I found a lot of this reading to be more of an elaboration of what was said in the text book. It's interesting to raise the question of if this history or not, because then we have to actually step back and define what history is. I believe that this is a historical piece of work and should be taken into account as history because it describes the past. It may have biases in it because it is written from one point of few, but I think that can be said with almost any historical document. (Almost) no matter what, there is a bit of bias in either how someone writes a piece of work, or how it is taken by the reader. As the reader, I find this to be historical.

Saturday, October 10, 2009

Two Thousand Years in the Heart of Asia - Chapter 4


This chapter of the course textbook immediately started off with compelling information. The Xiongnu, a nomadic shepherds inhabiting China’s northwestern borders (Mongolia), were so annoying and irritating to their Chinese farming neighbours (with their constant raids) that they actually provoked the construction of the first part of the Great Wall in Gansu. The Xiongnu name is often translated to ‘Huns’ which (as juvenile as it may sound) I immediately recognized and put into ‘context’ from Disney’s motion picture movie Mulan.

This perception of the Huns as deviants is made clear in the Chinese two-character name for them, literally meaning “fierce slaves’. This description of ‘fierce’ seems almost too passive when in Zhang Quan’s (envoy for the Wudi [Martial Emperor] of the Han) biography; he tells us that the Huns made a drinking vessel out of the king of the Yuezhi’s skull. Zhang was ironically imprisoned by the Huns for 10 years when on his mission to enlist support to drive the Huns back.

The sense of a ‘tribute relationship’ is a very interesting concept, because though the Huns demonstrated power over the Chinese, they were compliant with trade as well as in methods of balance with the Han. In order to avoid frontier war, the Han administration made arrangements with the Huns for each side to send ’hostages’ - princesses from the Han and sons of rulers from outside states (50)

What I really find intriguing is the diplomatic efforts of the Han in dealing with Loulan and Xiongnu relations. Hostages are frequently used, and a central feature of Han diplomacy was to use spare princesses to organize matrimonial alliances.

In addition to matrimonial arrangements, China sent out ten percent of the states revenue in ‘gifts’ such as silk, alcohol, rice and other foodstuffs to the Huns. These were called gifts only so that the Chinese could save face and not consider them ‘tributes’. The resentment towards the Hans is evident in a contemporary Chinese account that described them as good-for-nothing; a people abandoned by heaven.

Returning to the Han shu, the official history of the western Han (in which Zhang’s biography is found) there is a Chapter (96 to be exact) that is entitled ‘Description of the Western Regions’. This provided census information included amount of civilians, households, people able to bear arms, etc. This also showed the Han Chinese bureaucracy at work as it had information on registration for taxes as a vital part of the economy (52). Another intriguing development during the Han dynasty was establishment of custom posts and passports to prevent smuggling (59)

Besides these interesting origins, some other key points in this chapter that I found to be of importance were the great value and importance of horses, and the practice of passing a widowed wife on to someone else in the family.

Okay, that’s it for my Two Thousand Years in the Heart of Asia blog… now onto find the online reading!

p.s....
sorry I just had to youtube this link:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yz38PkCWxqU

Sunday, October 4, 2009

Paul Pelliot and Tun-huang Manuscripts


Hey everyone,

I found the picture of Pelliot in the secret chamber reviewing the Tun-huang (Dunhuang) manuscripts. The picture was referred to in the book, so I was curious and looked it up.


Enjoy!